Runner's Dilemma #17 — Why Do We Go Running When Something Is Bothering Us?
Runner's Log | Runner's Dilemma #17
Why Do We Go Running
When Something Is Bothering Us?
Wouldn't it be nice if life only handed us the light kind of worries?
Sometimes no amount of thinking gets you out of that misery — you just stay stuck in it. The more you turn it over, the worse direction it goes, and the heavier your heart gets.
At times like this, I see my late father in myself — the way he used to talk about things that hadn't even happened yet, dozens of times over, until the whole house felt heavy.
I try hard not to let it show around my kids. But my wife, right next to me, knows anyway, no matter how much I try to hide it.
And she pretends not to notice, so I won't feel burdened. I'm grateful for that, and it makes me a little sad, too.
In the end, stepping away for a while is the best thing I can do for myself.
There's a line I always say to my wife at times like this. And she always says the same thing back: "Sure."
What started as running for my health turned into a marathon habit once I got greedy for more fitness — and now, when a problem won't resolve no matter how much I think about it, I go out running with that same heaviness in my chest.
I imagine plenty of runners are a lot like me.
And it made me wonder, out of nowhere:
while running with that same worry actually makes it a little better?
I. Sitting Still, We Circle the Same Spot
Psychologist Susan Nolen-Hoeksema spent decades studying this.
When people replay the same problem over and over, it feels like thinking — like real analysis. But what actually grows isn't insight, it's just certainty that you understand the problem. It rarely leads to effective action.
Replay the same scene forty times, and nothing is different from the fifth replay.
No new information. No decision. No plan. Just a worse mood, and a deeper groove worn into the same thought.
Psychology calls this rumination — or more broadly, repetitive negative thinking (RNT).
Looking back, I think that was my father.
The same worry, in the same words, repeated dozens of times. The repeating never solved anything. It just kept the air in the house heavy.
II. When I Run, the Thought Circles the Problem Instead
But once I start running, the same worry somehow starts flowing in a different direction.
↓
"What's actually making me struggle here?"
↓
"Maybe this is just part of who I am — something I can't fully get rid of no matter what."
↓
"If that's true, maybe I just have to accept this much of it."
This isn't forcing myself to think positively.
It's closer to moving from replaying the problem to breaking down its structure.
A 2014 Stanford study (Oppezzo & Schwartz) tested exactly this. Comparing thinking while seated versus while walking, they found that walking clearly boosted divergent thinking — the ability to generate new ideas in many directions. The effect lingered even after the walking stopped.
But for convergent thinking — landing on a single correct answer — the effect was far more limited.
Thinking about it, the worries I carry while running are exactly that kind.
"Why am I struggling this much?"
"Do I need to just accept this situation?"
Not a problem with one calculable answer, but one that needs a wide look across many possibilities. And it's exactly this kind of worry where movement seems to help shift the direction of thought.
III. Why Would That Be?
A few things seem to work together here.
First, running doesn't let you hold onto a thought 100%.
Sitting still, you can pour every bit of mental resource into that one worry. But running demands your attention too — breathing, pace, footing, what's happening around you. The worry keeps going, but some of your attention scatters into your body and your surroundings. In that gap, you get a little room to look at the same thought from one step back.
Second, the questions themselves change.
Sitting still, the questions tend to point toward the past and future.
"What did I do wrong?"
"What's going to happen next?"
But running, oddly, brings questions back to the present.
"What can I actually do about it right now?"
Same problem, but the moment the question shifts, the direction of the thinking shifts with it.
The difference looks small, but it's actually significant.
The first kind of question just repeats when it can't find an answer. The second kind eventually generates options.
Third, the environment might matter more than we'd think.
A 2015 study compared a group who walked 90 minutes in a natural setting with a group who walked 90 minutes in an urban one.
Interestingly, only the nature-walk group showed reduced rumination, along with changes in activity in a brain region linked to rumination. The same amount of walking didn't produce the same result across the board.
Maybe it's not just the act of running that shifts my thinking — maybe stepping into a different space, moving along a path away from home, matters too.
Fourth, there's evidence that consistent running reduces rumination itself over time.
A 2025 systematic review pulling together 19 studies found that physical activity can help reduce repetitive negative thinking. But single sessions showed limited effect — the strongest results came from moderate-to-high intensity exercise, 30 to 60 minutes per session, three to five times a week, sustained over time.
In other words, resolving today's worry through one run, and someone who's run for years actually ruminating less as a baseline tendency, might be two somewhat different things.
I think I'm probably experiencing a bit of both.
IV. So, I Go Running
Sitting still, the thought flows like this:
Problem → emotion → problem → emotion → problem.
Running, it flows like this:
Problem → cause → why? → conditions → options → what to accept → conclusion.
Running with it, you circle around the problem, seeing it from different angles.
And after a run, it's rarely "the problem got solved."
More like, "ah, now I get why this was so hard."
For the hard problems, that usually has to come before any solution.
Maybe that was true for my late father, too.
It wasn't that he repeated the same story because there was no solution — maybe he just never knew how to think his way out of that misery.
Back then, I resented him for repeating the same things.
But now that I'm older, and I've been through a few worries of my own that never got resolved, I think I understand a little better.
And maybe,
just how much he was suffering, back then.
I'm not going out to solve the problem.
I'm not going out to forget it, either.
Just to carry myself — still circling the same thought — somewhere a little different.
I know how to live differently from my father.
References: Nolen-Hoeksema, S. (Response Styles Theory) · Oppezzo, M., & Schwartz, D. L. (2014). Give your ideas some legs: The positive effect of walking on creative thinking. Journal of Experimental Psychology: Learning, Memory, and Cognition, 40(4), 1142–1152. · Bratman, G. N. et al. (2015). Nature experience reduces rumination and subgenual prefrontal cortex activation. PNAS, 112(28), 8567–8572. · Wang, S., Lu, M., Dong, X., & Xu, Y. (2025). Does physical activity-based intervention decrease repetitive negative thinking? A systematic review. PLOS ONE, 20(4), e0319806.







